Instacart Advertising for CPG Brands: Why the Clicks Are Still Cheap

A brand we work with was in Costco and doing almost nothing on Instacart, and it wasn't because anyone had decided against it. Their team had looked at the account, seen a positive return coming off the automated setup, and moved on to something louder.

That account went on to grow 20x on Instacart sales. Trevor Hults at Tosí gave us his name and that number to use, and it's the cleanest example we have of the thing brands keep missing: on Instacart, the auction is closed to anyone without shelf space, which is why the clicks are still cheap for the brands that have it.

Your distribution is the barrier to entry on this channel, and you've already paid for it.

How is Instacart advertising different from Amazon or Google ads?

The difference is who's allowed to bid. On Amazon, you and I could invent a brand this afternoon, ship a pallet in, and start bidding on the same terms as a national label by Friday. On Google it's easier still, because nothing has to physically exist. Both auctions are open, and open auctions get crowded, which is what pushes cost per click up over time.

Instacart's auction is gated by physical retail. You can only advertise against a SKU sitting on the shelves of the retailers Instacart serves. A brand with no distribution can't buy its way into the room at any price. So the set of bidders in your category is roughly the set of brands already on the shelf next to you, and that's a much shorter list than the one competing for you on Amazon.

The practical result shows up in the numbers. Across the accounts we run, cost per click on Instacart sits below what the same brand pays on Amazon or Google for comparable intent, and it isn't because the traffic is worth less. The traffic is a grocery shopper filling a cart, so it's worth plenty. Fewer people are simply allowed to bid for it.

For a manufacturer with real retail distribution and a consumer line that's stalled online, this is the rare case where the thing that makes you slow, all that physical distribution you spent years building, is also the thing that makes a channel cheap for you and expensive for everyone else. If you've spent a decade getting onto those shelves, you earned an advantage here that no amount of ad budget can buy. That work was harder than anything we do, and it's worth saying so.

What ad formats does Instacart offer?

Sponsored products are the format built for sales, and with most of Instacart's sales happening in the first rows a shopper sees, they're the one to get right before anything else.

Instacart's own documentation describes sponsored products as best suited to sales-based objectives. They show on the homepage, in search results and while a shopper browses, and they're billed per click through a second-price auction. You pay when a shopper clicks, and an impression on its own costs nothing. Ads Manager offers optimized and manual bidding.

The other formats are mostly bought on impressions. Display ads are banners across storefronts, departments and aisles. Shoppable display bundles several of your items with brand imagery and appears in search results, and shoppable video does the same job with video. Inspiration ads put your products inside recipes. Brands can also run promotions such as spend-and-save offers and free gift campaigns, grouped so each promotion reports on its own.

Two newer pieces are worth knowing about. Since April 2025, shoppable display campaigns extend automatically to Caper Carts, the smart carts with screens that shoppers push around a physical store, and those ads appear only in the relevant aisle when the item is in stock. Instacart also syndicates campaigns beyond its own marketplace to retailers' grocery sites. A single campaign follows a SKU to wherever it's sold and in stock.

The format list changes more often than the auction does. Every one of them is still attached to a product a partner retailer stocks, and that's what keeps the bidding pool short.

How much of grocery happens on Instacart?

About a fifth of US grocery spending now happens online, by NielsenIQ's count, and among the third-party apps that deliver from other people's stores, Instacart is the largest. The category is getting more crowded at the edges as DoorDash and Uber Eats push further into grocery, but Instacart remains the one with the retailer relationships and the ad infrastructure built out.

The part that surprises brand teams is that this isn't a decision they get to make. If your product is stocked in an Instacart partner retailer, it's being sold on Instacart right now. There's a listing, there's a price, there are competitors appearing beside you, and there's an auction running whether or not anyone on your side is participating in it. A retail-first brand is in the same position with its Amazon page, read by shoppers in the aisle whether or not anyone manages it.

We were slow to take this seriously ourselves, so this isn't us scolding anyone. The question was never whether to be on Instacart, because you're on it already. The question is whether anyone is managing what happens there, and for most brands with good retail distribution the honest answer is no.

Why does ad placement matter so much on Instacart?

Instacart's team has told us that something like 70% to 80% of sales on the platform happen within the first couple of rows a shopper sees. A grocery shopper filling a weekly cart is not browsing to page four. They're scanning, tapping, and moving on to the next item on the list.

That concentration changes what advertising is for. On a channel where shoppers browse deeply, ads supplement organic discovery. On Instacart, position in those first rows is most of the sale, which is why a well-run account can see the large majority of its platform revenue coming through ads. On one specialty ingredient account we manage, ad-attributed sales run consistently above 80% of the total, and that isn't a sign of something broken.

Which brings up the caveat we'd rather give you now than have you discover in month three.

Instacart ads don't build organic rank the way Amazon ads do. On Amazon, sales velocity from paid placement feeds organic ranking, so a well-run account gradually earns traffic it stops paying for. Instacart doesn't work that way. The ad contribution stays high, and pulling spend back tends to pull sales back with it rather than revealing an organic base underneath. Anyone selling you Instacart as a channel you'll eventually stop paying for is either new to it or hoping you don't check.

How much does Instacart advertising cost?

Instacart doesn't publish a rate card or a minimum spend, so the cost is whatever you bid per click, and the number worth planning around is what that click returns next to your other channels.

Sponsored product clicks are priced in an auction. The cost moves with your category and with how many of the brands on the shelf beside you are bidding. In the accounts we run, that's still a smaller group than on Amazon, and clicks come in under what the same brand pays on Amazon or Google for comparable intent.

Return is the better thing to plan around. Trevor Hults at Tosí described where our work had taken them like this: "By month two our sales were more than 10x over the baseline that we had previously with a ROAS of 4.5." On the specialty ingredient account above, a recent month returned roughly 4x on ad spend, with about 85% of the brand's Instacart sales coming through ads.

Read those two figures together. A 4x return on a channel where ads carry 85% of sales is an ongoing cost of selling there, and the budget should be built as one. Brands coming from Amazon tend to treat Instacart spend as a launch cost they'll taper once organic catches up, and on Instacart organic doesn't catch up the same way.

The other cost is management, and it's the reason we qualify accounts by door count further down.

Should Instacart ads come out of the marketing budget or the trade budget?

Trade, in most cases, and this is the single most useful reframe we can offer a brand that thinks it can't afford this channel.

Brands are starting to tell buyers that they'll skip a couple of in-store ad placements next year and put that money into retail media instead, and the response from buyers has been better than most brand teams expect. A broker we've worked with confirmed the same pattern from their side of the table, which matters more than us saying it, because they sit between the brand and the buyer and watch those conversations land.

The argument holds up because of what you can measure. A demo lifts velocity, and almost nobody can tell you afterwards which products it moved. Instacart spend can be sliced by SKU and by retailer, so you can see which products moved and where. For a brand that's been asked to justify trade spend with numbers it doesn't have, this is a line item that answers the question.

That distinction also matters for the size of the pot. A marketing budget at a mid-sized CPG brand is usually small and heavily spoken for. The trade and promotions budget is a different order of magnitude, and this spend has a legitimate claim on it.

There's one difference worth being honest about. Retailers require promotions and trade, and brands spend that money without anyone having to convince them. Nobody requires Instacart, and the channel has to show its return before it earns any of that budget. That's why the measurement matters so much. You have to spend this money somehow, and it may as well go somewhere you can show a return and the numbers aren't so fuzzy.

Do Instacart ads help in-store sales?

Instacart says they do, and puts the in-store halo at a 21% sales lift, but that's the platform reporting on itself, and it's worth checking against your own store data before you build a budget on it.

The 21% comes from Circana data on shoppers exposed to Instacart ads between April and mid-June 2024, compared with a control group, and Instacart notes the method differs from its own lift studies. It also cites a 25% average incremental sales lift from earlier published tests. Neither is a number I'd promise a client.

What carries more weight with a buyer is data you can produce yourself. If Instacart spend rises in a market and your scan data in that market rises with it, that's evidence you own, and it fits the trade-budget argument above. You can show which SKUs moved and where, and a demo can't.

Do my Instacart ads run at every retailer, or can I pick?

Your ads are placed against a SKU, so they surface wherever that SKU is stocked across Instacart's partner retailers. You don't get clean per-retailer control by default, and this catches brands out more often than any other mechanic on the platform.

There are two partial exceptions worth knowing. Some retailers, Sprouts among them, run separate sub-accounts, so promotions there can be isolated from the rest. And if you sell different pack sizes into different retailers, those count as different SKUs, which gives you a lever that looks like retailer targeting even though it's really pack architecture.

This turns into a commercial problem once a broker is involved. A broker contracted for the natural channel but not for Costco, Walmart or Target can end up driving sales into retailers they aren't compensated for, and there's no clean way to switch that off inside the platform. It's solvable in the contract. It just has to be solved before the campaigns run, not after the first month's report raises the question.

What should you look at first in an Instacart account?

Start with how many Instacart partner doors the brand is in, then what's live in the account and what's been done with ads, because those three tell you how big the opportunity is before anyone spends anything.

When we offer a brand a free takeover, the intake is short. Send us a spreadsheet of your retail locations, because we need to know how many Instacart partner doors you're in. Then, ideally, access to the back end of the Instacart account. That shows us how many SKUs are in there and what's been done with ads so far.

Some brands don't have an account at all. If you're stocked in any Instacart partner retailer, you have sales going through Instacart, and plenty of brands have never set up the account that would let them see those sales or influence them. Others have an agency that lists Instacart as an extension of what it does, and there the audit question is whether anyone is managing it or whether it's an afterthought.

Not every door counts the same, either. Your opportunity is set by the number of stores you're in and by which retailers they are. Costco is the one I get excited about, and a brand that's in Costco and not advertising on Instacart is one of several signals that an account is about to move. Retailers with their own sub-accounts, like Sprouts, change how much of the account you can segment, and the pack sizes you sell into each retailer decide the rest.

Should your broker, an agency or someone in-house run Instacart?

Whoever runs it has to be able to work the whole account across every retailer, because the ads can't be fenced off by banner, and the commercial setup has to allow for that before anyone picks a provider.

Brokers are an obvious candidate, and the sticking point is the one in the section above: the ads drive sales at retailers the broker isn't paid on. A contract that covers platform-driven sales can solve it, and brands generally want to see performance across the board without caring which retailer the sales come through.

For a brand thinking about doing it in-house, I'd separate two hires that look like one. Finding the best channel specialist you can is a different job from finding the person who can build the team for that channel, and it's worth knowing which one you need before you write the job description.

Size of brand matters less than whether leadership sees the channel as worth managing. Mid-sized brands are often the best fit, because they've reached a meaningful level of distribution and are still nimble enough to make fast decisions. Enterprise brands have far more opportunity, and the same channel can sit ignored for a long time when every decision goes through a committee. We're an Amazon agency first, and Instacart is how we follow a brand onto the next shelf.

When is Instacart worth managing properly?

The qualifying number we use is retail doors. Below roughly 1,000 Instacart partner doors, the ceiling is usually too low to carry management fees and still leave the brand better off. Above about 2,000 doors, we've yet to see an account where careful management didn't move sales in a way the brand could feel.

Two other signals are worth checking before anyone spends anything:

  • Costco distribution. Costco overperforms on Instacart relative to its share of a brand's physical sales, so a brand that's in Costco and running nothing on Instacart is usually sitting on the largest single gap in its account.
  • A positive return on automated ads. This one is counterintuitive. If you switched Instacart ads on, left them automated, and they're returning a profit, leaving them alone is the expensive option, because being profitable on the platform's default settings with nobody steering is the clearest signal in the account that managed spend would return several times more.

The product matters as well as the doors. A common objection is that nobody orders a product like a greens powder on Instacart, because nobody needs it in the next hour, and at that price point the purchase happens on Amazon. For a considered, stock-up product that's a fair point. My answer is that it depends on how many retail doors the brand is still in, and that's why the door count comes first.

If neither of those is true and your door count is low, the honest answer is that this channel can wait. We'd rather tell you that now than take a retainer for twelve months of managing something that was never going to carry it. If most of your distribution is independent health-food and specialty shops rather than chain grocery, the door count may not get there for a while, and building the wholesale side on Faire is probably the more useful next step.

The bottom line

If your brand has real retail distribution and nobody is managing Instacart, you're leaving the cheapest media you have access to sitting unclaimed, and the shoppers are there either way. The auction is small because your competitors are limited to the brands beside you on the shelf, and that advantage doesn't last forever.

We'll take one of your accounts for 30 days at no cost and show you what the lift looks like, on the condition that we pick the account. If the numbers don't move, you've lost nothing and you'll know where this channel sits for your brand. If they do, you'll have the read you needed to make the budget argument internally.

You've built the distribution. It should be paying you twice.

cta_free_trial

‍

Read more blogs

How to Increase Amazon Sales Without Buying Them: The Amazon Profit System
  • Amazon

How to Increase Amazon Sales Without Buying Them: The Amazon Profit System

How to Increase Amazon Sales Without Buying Them: The Amazon Profit System
Flat for Two Years, Then +60%: A Specialty Ingredient Brand's Amazon Turnaround
  • Amazon
  • Case Study
  • Natural CPG

Flat for Two Years, Then +60%: A Specialty Ingredient Brand's Amazon Turnaround

Flat for Two Years, Then +60%: A Specialty Ingredient Brand's Amazon Turnaround
From Break-Even Ads to Roughly 10x Profit: A Natural Snack Brand's Amazon Turnaround
  • Case Study
  • Natural CPG
  • Amazon

From Break-Even Ads to Roughly 10x Profit: A Natural Snack Brand's Amazon Turnaround

From Break-Even Ads to Roughly 10x Profit: A Natural Snack Brand's Amazon Turnaround

Find out what your Amazon channel really earns

Apply for a free trial of our work, or chat with our team. Either way you'll leave knowing your true profit, which is more than your current reports can tell you. And if we work together and miss the targets we set, the sprint to fix it is on us.